Architecture 12010

I think Amsterdam has some amazing architecture within the city. I write a lot about preserving examples of architecture from periods long past but what about the recent periods of architecture.

What prompted this post is the building housing the Amsterdam Police Department at 1 Guy Park Ave. Here are some street views of the building: 

apd3 apd2 apd1

I’ll admit to not liking the building for a myriad of reasons — the scale, its ‘coldness’, its symbolism as a creation enabled by urban renewal and the arterials cutting through the city, .. I could go on.

With my curiosity piqued as to the architectural origin of the building, I did a little research and found that , from what I can discern, the building appears to be of an architectural style called ‘brutalist’.

Here is an explanation of the origin and the term: 

Like International style, Brutalism is sometimes classified as its own distinctive subtype, though it is considered a variant of post-war modernism. Despite its apparently appropriate name, Brutalism is derived from the French term, beton brut, which translates to “rough concrete”. It is essentially a style based on the shaped and molded forms of concrete, a thick, masonry variation of modernist architecture. Regardless of how the International style, Modernism, and Brutalism are classified, they all share the fundamental modernist principle promoted by Louis Sullivan and his contemporaries and successors, that “form forever follows function,” without relying on revivalist architectural styles of the past.

As someone who harps endlessly on preserving versus demolition, I have to admit it’s hard to muster the same energy when faced with the question of the fate of  brutalist buildings.

I think I’m coming around somewhat but can’t deny that I agree with this: 

 [snip] as Manhattan Institute fellow Theodore Dalrymple who wrote a book about the work of Brutalist architect Le Corbusier and told the New York Times that Brutalism is “absolutely hideous, like scouring pads on the retina.”

About these ads

5 thoughts on “Architecture 12010

  1. Ugh, some of the best (as in not a compliment) examples of this terrible movement are also found just 30 miles away in Albany, right across from some stunning examples of public buildings that actually are beautiful.

    • I don’t agree as a police station is still part of the fabric of its community and if the police building is meant to be cold, imposing then why do so many communities , including ours, spend time and effort by the police on ‘warm, fuzzy’ issues like community outreach, neighborhood watch, volunteerism, et al. I think a police building serves multiple goals, audiences and purposes.

      Here is a counterpoint: http://www.archdaily.com/146219/sarasota-police-department-headquarters-architects-design-group/

      • I probably should have put a :) after the comment. My tongue was planted firmly in cheek when I posted it.

        In all honesty, I’m not a big fan of generic, cookie-cutter concrete monstrosities. They’re right up there with those “cobra” street lamps that have no personality or character whatsoever.

  2. The benefit of the architecture is meant to reduce construction cost and cut down on maintenance issues such as painting. It is a simple approach to architecture based on the three F’s, form, fit and function. I think if my memory serves me right, the architectural firm was Fiebs and Schmight (sp). I believe some of the inspiration for the building was the architecture of the FGI building. I myself appreciate the other forms of architecture but also have an appreciation for the “modern” design.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s